Est. Prospect, Ohio
Hello, neighbor. Come on in.
Prospect Dairy Bar has been a quiet delight on North Elm Street — a place where hand-spun ice cream tastes like summer, and every visit feels like coming home.
Scroll
Est. Prospect, Ohio
Prospect Dairy Bar has been a quiet delight on North Elm Street — a place where hand-spun ice cream tastes like summer, and every visit feels like coming home.
Our Story
For decades, Prospect Dairy Bar has stood on North Elm Street as a neighborhood staple — the kind of place where regulars know the owner by name and the ice cream machine never seems to stop.
We started with a simple idea: make ice cream the way your grandmother would have wanted — real cream, real flavor, real care. Over the years, that philosophy has only deepened. Our sundaes are built by hand. Our toppings are chosen with intention. And our waffle cones are still made fresh, every single day.
Whether you're a local who's been coming since you were six, or you're passing through and stumbled in on a warm afternoon — we're glad you found us. Pull up a stool. Stay a while.
Fresh batches every morning
Real ingredients, real flavor
A welcoming spot for all ages
151-199 N Elm St, Prospect
What We Offer
Every scoop is hand-spun, every topping thoughtfully chosen. Here's what makes a visit to Prospect Dairy Bar special.
Classic and seasonal flavors, hand-spun fresh every morning. Single or double scoops — in a cup, a classic cone, or a freshly made waffle cone.
Start with two scoops and build up. Hot fudge, caramel, whipped cream, chopped nuts, maraschino cherries — or let us surprise you with the house special.
Hand-shaken to order — thick, cold, and exactly as sweet as you like them. Root beer floats are a Prospect favorite.
Good coffee, cold sodas, and everything in between. A warm cup on a chilly morning or a soda on a hot afternoon — we've got you covered.
Cookies, brownies, and seasonal pastries — perfect alongside an ice cream or on their own. Made fresh and rotated regularly.
Planning a gathering? We prepare party trays with an assortment of flavors and toppings — easy to serve, impossible to forget.
"There's something about Prospect Dairy Bar that makes you want to come back — the ice cream, sure, but also the feeling that you're exactly where you're supposed to be."
A Prospect regular
Visit Us
151-199 N Elm St
Prospect, OH 43342
151-199 N Elm St, Prospect, OH 43342
Get in Touch
Have a question, a suggestion, or want to place a party tray order? Drop us a line and we'll get back to you as soon as we can.
